What Bangladeshi-Americans Can Learn from the Pakistani Diaspora
Reflections on the Georgetown Pakistan Forum, institution-building, and the promise of South Asian-American solidarity
I left the 2026 Georgetown Pakistan Forum with my mind buzzing, my notebook full, and a renewed appreciation for what diaspora communities can accomplish when they organize around a shared sense of purpose.
I attended the Forum for the first time with my team from the American Bangladesh Foundation (ABF), which had the privilege of serving as a sponsoring organization. ABF is a new nonprofit dedicated to developing the next generation of Bangladeshi-American leaders, advancing policy research, and strengthening cooperation between the United States, Bangladesh, and the broader South Asian region.
As a Bangladeshi-American building an institution of our own, I found the experience inspiring, humbling, and occasionally amusing. It also made me reflect on what our community can learn from our South Asian neighbors.
These are my personal reflections and do not necessarily represent the views of ABF or its leadership.
The Virtue of Institutional Thick Skin
One of the most remarkable aspects of the Forum was the willingness of the Embassy of Pakistan to support a gathering where the country's most powerful institutions faced sustained and sometimes blistering criticism.
Speaker after speaker decried Pakistan's democratic shortcomings, weak civilian institutions, and the military's longstanding dominance over political life.
Yet Pakistan's Ambassador to the United States, Rizwan Saeed Sheikh, and members of his team attended the proceedings. The Ambassador even participated in a fireside conversation with the outspoken, Academy Award-winning filmmaker Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy.
Perhaps the military's influence is so entrenched, so much a fait accompli, that criticism from academics and diaspora activists poses little threat to the established order.
Conversely, I suspect many Embassy diplomats may have genuinely appreciated the calls for stronger civilian governance.
I did wonder what any serving or retired military officers in attendance made of the proceedings. Diplomatic openness, of course, should not be confused with institutional accountability.
Nevertheless, I found the experience refreshing. South Asian political cultures too often conflate criticism of a government with criticism of the nation itself.
The Forum offered a counter-example: institutions confident enough to listen to their critics without treating disagreement as disloyalty.
Bangladesh's governments, regardless of which party holds power, should aspire to similar maturity. Rather than marginalizing or silencing critical voices, they should demonstrate the confidence to engage them constructively.
The same responsibility extends to supporters of our major political parties, who too often treat political disagreement as an existential struggle against "the other side."
There is profound power in civility. Constructive criticism and rational debate foster institutional maturity and national dignity. Conversely, relentless partisan warfare, intolerance of dissent, and censorship alienate the very people whose participation is essential to democracy.
I suspect this helps explain why many Bangladeshis, at home and abroad, disengage from national politics altogether, limiting their connection to Bangladesh to cultural celebrations and family ties, if they remain engaged at all.
Political Differences Need Not Prevent Collective Action
The Forum also demonstrated something Bangladeshi-Americans desperately need to learn: a diaspora can be politically divided without allowing those divisions to consume every aspect of its collective life.
Pakistani-Americans have profound disagreements over Pakistan's political future, including Imran Khan's imprisonment and the military's political influence. Yet at Georgetown, participants could still engage on common challenges: public health, energy security, environmental degradation, economic development, and diplomacy.
They did not need to agree on every political question to recognize that these issues deserved attention.
Our diaspora is similarly diverse. Many younger Bangladeshi-Americans, particularly those of my generation and younger, appear relatively disengaged from Bangladesh's party politics. Yet among politically engaged segments of our community, polarization can be extraordinary.
Political loyalties sometimes determine which organizations people join, whom they trust, and which initiatives they support.
At ABF, we are fiercely non-partisan. We believe Bangladesh's domestic political future belongs, first and foremost, to the people who live there and must bear the consequences of political decisions.
I hold an even stronger personal conviction. Having built my life in the United States with no intention of permanently relocating to Bangladesh, I am deeply uncomfortable with the idea of voting in Bangladeshi elections.
I recognize that expatriates maintain substantial ties to their homeland and that reasonable people disagree about overseas voting rights. But I do not have to live with the full consequences of my electoral choices.
My relatives, friends, and millions of Bangladeshis do. It would strike me as arrogant to assume my judgment should carry the same electoral weight as theirs.
This does not mean the diaspora should remain silent. We can support human rights, democratic institutions, education, research, and international partnerships without becoming extensions of Bangladesh's political parties.
Unfortunately, partisanship is only one obstacle. Our community also struggles with regionalism, class divisions, interpersonal rivalries, and a deeply ingrained scarcity mentality. I sometimes joke that every Bangladeshi has either been scammed or knows someone who has.
The joke is exaggerated, but it reflects a genuine challenge: understandable caution can harden into reflexive suspicion of new initiatives and unfamiliar leaders.
The result is a fragmented landscape of small, underfunded organizations competing for limited resources, rather than pooling them to build enduring institutions. It also complicates the work of Bangladeshi diplomatic missions, where engagement with one group risks being interpreted as favoritism toward another.
Compare this with Pakistani-American institutions such as the Association of Physicians of Pakistani Descent of North America (APPNA), which has developed a substantial platform for professional engagement and philanthropy. Pakistani-Americans certainly have their divisions, but the Forum demonstrated that political disagreement need not preclude cooperation.
Pakistani-diaspora Perfectionism?
At the risk of becoming that annoying South Asian uncle who insists on comparing everyone's accomplishments at the dinner table, I couldn't help noticing a fascinating difference between how Pakistani-Americans and Bangladeshi-Americans discuss their relationships with their ancestral homelands.
One of the most fascinating discussions at the Forum concerned whether the Pakistani diaspora had, in some sense, "failed Pakistan." As an outsider, I found the premise astonishing.
Here was a community with established professional associations, philanthropic networks, accomplished public intellectuals, and considerable economic and political influence, debating whether it had done enough.
The contrast with Bangladesh was striking. During the IMF and World Bank Annual Meetings, I had the pleasure of attending an Atlantic Council event where Bangladesh's Finance Minister acknowledged that the Bangladeshi state has long struggled to harness the talents and resources of its diaspora, particularly compared with its South Asian neighbors.
I subsequently wrote a Counterpoint op-ed urging the government to remove barriers to academic and business collaboration and make it easier for overseas Bangladeshis to contribute to the country's development.
Indeed, the prevailing narrative within the Bangladeshi diaspora seems to be almost the exact opposite of what I heard at Georgetown: It is the Bangladeshi state that has failed its diaspora, rather than the diaspora that has failed Bangladesh.
There is considerable merit to this criticism. But it also raises an uncomfortable question: Have we become so accustomed to expecting the government to facilitate diaspora engagement that we have neglected to ask what more we can accomplish ourselves, independently of the state?
At Georgetown, some participants argued that Pakistani-Americans should use their "affluence for influence" to promote democracy and constrain the military's dominance. I understood the frustration, but wondered whether the expectations were realistic.
Should families withhold remittances from relatives? Should philanthropists reconsider supporting essential education and health initiatives in the hope of weakening a military establishment entrenched since Pakistan's earliest decades -- and largely backed by the world’s superpower?
Such expectations risk confusing the responsibilities of a diaspora with those of the state, particularly when the immediate costs would fall on ordinary families.
And yet I admired the ambition behind the criticism.
Perhaps this is the Pakistani-American version of a Type A personality: exceptionally accomplished, relentlessly self-critical, and never quite satisfied.
As a Bangladeshi-American, I found this simultaneously inspiring and faintly amusing. Our community is still developing many of the professional networks and philanthropic institutions that Pakistani-Americans have spent decades building. Meanwhile, some Pakistani-Americans are debating whether their institutions have sufficiently transformed their homeland's political order!
Of course, longevity and institutional scale do not automatically translate into effectiveness. Many criticisms of organizations such as APPNA are entirely merited. Yet perfectionism should not obscure progress.
I hope Bangladeshi-Americans eventually reach the point where we debate not merely whether our institutions can survive, but whether they are sufficiently ambitious and influential. We should certainly demand that Bangladesh's government do more to engage its diaspora, but we should also hold ourselves to higher standards of collective action, philanthropy, and institution-building.
There is a profound difference between genuine patriotism, which asks what we owe our communities, and hollow nationalism, which asks only whom we should praise or condemn.
The former builds institutions. The latter too often divides them.
Solidarity, Women, and the People Who Actually Build Institutions
Another lesson from the Forum concerned the people who actually build institutions.
I was struck by the contributions of non-Pakistanis to Pakistan-related causes. This resonated with my experience building ABF. Some of our most generous leaders, mentors, and supporters are not Bangladeshi.
Indeed, I have sometimes found it easier to explain ABF's mission to non-Bangladeshis than to members of our own community. Many immediately recognize the importance of independent, nonpartisan institutions and have generously shared their expertise, networks, and time.
This has reinforced my belief that diaspora institution-building should never become an exercise in ethnic exclusivity. Solidarity is not merely a principle. It is a practical necessity. The strongest organizations unite people around a shared mission, not merely a shared birthplace.
The Forum also reminded me that women do far more than half the work of sustaining our institutions. I was struck by how many sponsoring organizations' tables were staffed by women. At ABF, our participation was naturally limited to team members based in the DC area or visiting at the time.
Yet as our new Senior Fellow pointed out to me, every member of our team who joined me at the Forum was a woman, including several new colleagues who came aboard after we extended an invitation to attend the Forum as part of the ABF team at no cost.
It was both an inspiring and sobering reminder of the enthusiasm, initiative, and commitment that women bring to building and sustaining our institutions.
Throughout my career, I have witnessed women undertaking the painstaking, often unglamorous work of institution-building: cultivating relationships, mentoring colleagues, managing programs, and keeping organizations functioning.
I remember a dear Sri Lankan colleague who led a rights-based think tank that my former organization supported. She explained that she felt unable to step down because she had struggled to groom a woman successor. In her experience, men were often quick to assume leadership positions and claim credit without undertaking the years of patient work that made those positions possible.
Her observation has stayed with me.
At ABF, I have tried to ensure that women leaders are not merely visible, but genuinely empowered. The fact that our Chairperson and both Vice-Chairpersons are women is no accident. Their judgment, experience, and leadership are indispensable to our mission.
I have also noticed something that deserves deeper reflection: women are often among the most generous with their time and the most dedicated to producing high-quality work, even in unpaid positions.
I do not believe this is because women are inherently more altruistic or hardworking than men. Rather, I suspect it reflects deeply rooted structural and societal dynamics that shape the opportunities, expectations, and incentives facing both genders.
Men, for example, are often expected to be, or actually are, their families' primary breadwinners, which can make unpaid work a difficult proposition. Women, meanwhile, may face different pressures and barriers that influence how their contributions are valued and compensated.
There are, of course, wonderful exceptions to any generalization. For instance, our Secretary and another Advisory Council member have contributed their expertise to co-author several publications with me, while the creative genius behind ABF's website has generously contributed his considerable talents to our mission.
Yet this raises a larger question: Why are women so often willing to volunteer their time and talents to sustain institutions and advance causes that benefit entire communities, while comparatively fewer men seem willing to do the same?
I recognize that economic pressures and societal expectations, including the expectation that men serve as primary breadwinners, can shape these decisions.
But I also wonder whether we have normalized a culture in which men are more willing to champion a cause in principle than to contribute the unpaid labor necessary to advance it.
If we believe that Bangladeshi Americans deserve a stronger voice in Washington's policy community, for example, shouldn't more of us be willing to invest our own time and talents in building the institutions that can make that possible?
Leadership, after all, is not just about having a seat at the table. It is also about helping build the table in the first place.
If we want stronger institutions, we must ensure that those doing the work receive the authority, recognition, and opportunities they deserve.
Building Institutions That Outlive Their Founders
One observation at the Forum particularly caught my attention: an expert remarked that many Pakistani organizations, whether businesses, think tanks, or other institutions, struggle to survive beyond their founders.
I immediately thought about ABF.
Like many new organizations, ABF began with a personal vision: to create the kind of institution I wished had existed when I was a younger Bangladeshi-American. But I am acutely conscious of the dangers of "founder's syndrome," where an organization becomes so dependent on its founder that it struggles to develop independent leadership or survive a transition.
That is why I believe governance must be meaningful both de jure and de facto: not merely reflected in bylaws, but practiced in everyday decision-making.
Our board must exercise genuine oversight, senior leaders must have real authority, and younger colleagues must feel empowered to challenge assumptions. A good idea can come from anywhere, from our Chairperson to one of our volunteer research and program associates.
I do not want ABF to become an institution dependent on my constant presence or approval. I want it to thrive without me.
Ultimately, the measure of a founder's success may be how unnecessary they eventually become.
Personal initiative can launch an organization. Only shared ownership can sustain it.
A South Asian-American Future Worth Building
The Georgetown Pakistan Forum left me with more questions than answers, which is perhaps the highest compliment I can pay an intellectual gathering.
I came away with renewed respect for the Pakistani-American community's accomplishments, its willingness to engage in uncomfortable self-examination, and its determination to contribute to Pakistan's future. I also came away thinking about how much Bangladeshi-Americans can learn from our Pakistani, Indian, and Sri Lankan neighbors.
Each diaspora has its own history, divisions, strengths, and blind spots. None offers a perfect model. But we share experiences of migration, intergenerational change, political polarization, and the complicated relationship between attachment to a homeland and responsibility to an adopted country.
One of my favorite moments at the Forum was seeing ABF's table situated next to that of the American Pakistan Foundation, an organization whose example helped inspire our own creation. There was something deeply poetic about that proximity -- as if it was kismoth (fate).
It reminded me that institution-building must not be a zero-sum endeavor. Another diaspora's success does not diminish our own prospects. On the contrary, it can provide a model, a partner, and a source of encouragement.
We hope to build upon this spirit of collaboration by working with the Georgetown University South Asian Society on a future forum highlighting Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Nepal.
Above all, the Forum reminded me of the institutions we should aspire to build: intellectually open, politically independent, inclusive in their leadership, generous in their partnerships, and durable enough to outlive their founders.
We need to replace the instinct to compete for influence within our communities with the ambition to build influence together.
That, to me, is a far more compelling expression of patriotism than any flag-waving or partisan slogan.
It is also a legacy worth building.
Atif A. Choudhury is the Founder and CEO of the American Bangladesh Foundation (ABF), a nonpartisan nonprofit dedicated to developing future leaders, advancing policy research, and strengthening US-Bangladesh and regional cooperation. The views expressed here are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of ABF or its leadership.